Reviewed by You is a blog section in the What's New Blog that began on May 11, 2018. It was ran by Lataus from May 2018 through April 2020, and by Skyver in May 2020.

In Reviewed by You, an open-ended question is given on the blog each week. The question usually talks about current events, mini-games and mascots. Penguins can respond to the question on the blog by commenting on the post itself.

Two penguins' answers would be featured in the next Reviewed by You and they would also win 5,000 coins each.

On May 17, 2020, Skyver announced his resignation from the Club Penguin Rewritten team. It is currently unknown if Reviewed by You will continue.


Date Title Question Previous winners
May 11, 2018 Puffle Pals If you could be any color of Puffle, what would you be and why? None
May 18, 2018 Medieval Costumes Who are you dressing up as this year? Looplox and Ryan
May 25, 2018 Medieval Adventures What adventures have you had during the Medieval Party so far? Fajardo and Purple_Alien
June 1, 2018 Medieval Party Review What did you think of the Medieval Party 2018? Blue Dust and Halopona
June 8, 2018 Penguins at Work What is your favorite Penguins at Work job? 8JKN4 and Little007
June 15, 2018 Favorite Instrument What is your favorite instrument? Peidovermei and Static
June 22, 2018 Penguin Band Who is your favorite member of the Penguin Band? Talls2882 and UnknitBloom6
June 29, 2018 Music Jam Review What were your favorite moments from the Music Jam 2018? Clubby8911 and MsNeRdY
July 6, 2018 Sports Superstars What is your favorite sport to play on the island, and why? Pumpkinpi714 and Harrypopins1
July 13, 2018 Ocean Voyage If you could go anywhere in the world with Rockhopper and Yarr, where would you go? Flipper9038 and Tadman12
July 20, 2018 Island Adventure What kind of adventures have you been having to prepare for the Adventure Party? Jerald1 and CookieBrick
July 27, 2018 Pirates vs Captains Will you be siding with Team Pirate or Team Captain? RyanjcCPR and 8JKN4
August 3, 2018 Island Adventure Party Review What are your favorite experiences from the Adventure Party? Poppy Noppy and Arso Nist
August 10, 2018 Minigame Mania What is your favorite minigame to earn coins from? BasketBallr and Perapin
August 18, 2018 Igloo Decor What is must in your igloo, and what are your favorite igloo items that you like using? Spacecookie and Pinguim Mj
August 24, 2018 Summer Activities What fun summer activities you enjoy doing on the island? Wetdog15 and Panther111
August 31, 2018 Sled Racers Do you prefer racing with your friends using the default inner tube or the sleds that can be purchased from the Game Upgrades catalog? Broday and Derourkl
September 7, 2018 Red vs Blue Are you supporting Team Blue or are you supporting Team Red, and for what reason? Nikolaj35 and ClaraAnn26
September 14, 2018 101 Days of Summer What have you enjoyed about 101 Days of Fun and what have been your favorite activities from it? SweetMacaron and Supershox
September 21, 2018 A Fair Surprise What are you looking forward to seeing at The Fair? Carosene and MellowMarshy
September 29, 2018 Fair Games What fair game do you find most enjoyable playing at The Fair? Nandovshiki and Cutpuke
October 5, 2018 The Fair Review What did you enjoy about The Fair and what were your favorite memories from it? Crescenzio and Teart
October 12, 2018 Spooky Costumes What Halloween costume have you got prepared this year? BananaMoose and Yzma
October 19, 2018 Ecliptic Eerie What are your feelings and opinions about the eclipse. Any theories of how it happened? Rusty47199 and SparkleSpots567
October 26, 2018 Not a Ghost of a Chance What in your opinion makes us ghosts who we are? Is there any special requirements you think we should have? Pillow and WinterSoup90
November 3, 2018 Halloween Party Review What are your favorite moments and experiences from the Halloween Party? Shirokappa and Kavoor
November 9, 2018 Ninja Training What Card Jitsu Belt are you currently on, and and how are you going to train to get the next one? OriginalXsgh and Sweet KItty
November 16, 2018 Light the Lighthouse What are some of your favorite moments and memories at the Beacon? Coolpengu041 and Jjtaycay
November 23, 2018 Ice Hockey What is your preferred team color that you usually play or support in ice hockey? RulerX and kellyman7
November 30, 2018 Card Jitsu Fire What are you most excited for towards training to become a Fire Ninja? Ziva26a and Wizards34
December 8, 2018 Preparing for the Holidays How are you preparing for this Holiday season around the island? Lorelion and YipYorp
December 14, 2018 Coins for Change How many coins are you planning on donating to help out for Coins for Change? Mcparrot and EllycraftsYT
December 22, 2018 Festive Favors What do you enjoy most about the Holidays? Garnet1200 and Silonana
December 29, 2018 Highlights of the Year What are your favourite moments and memories from 2018 overall? LoneWolf1256 and May14

Date Title Question Previous winners
January 4, 2019 Dance Contest What is your favorite Dance Contest track to play against your friends? Derpymangoes and Limey312
January 11, 2019 Collecting Stamps How many stamps do you own and which ones do you treasure the most from your collections? Turquoisey1 and Bubba4081
January 19, 2019 Fiesta Time! What are you going to do to celebrate the Winter Fiesta? Ashlyn909 and Pinkowlcat
January 26, 2019 Fashion Frenzy To celebrate your fabulous fashionista outfits, this week we would like to know what your favorite type of fashion theme is. Penguinbobi1 and Hidden Pengu
February 1, 2019 Redesign Reflection What are your thoughts and feelings about the new design of the blog redesign? polarbear258 and MeggPeng
February 9, 2019 Anniversary Memories In our second year, what parties and events did you enjoy most on the island with your buddies? Harrypopins1 and Weeem
February 15, 2019 3, 2, 1... Action! What do you enjoy most about new plays coming to the Stage? CherrySakura and MrNoah
February 23, 2019 Deep Sea Discoveries What do you enjoy most about this new watery experience? LB Wingman and AwesomeFlor
March 2, 2019 Going Places If you could be hang out with any mascot for a day, who would it be and why? Edudude and KayKainoa77
March 8, 2019 Lucky Preparations How are you encouraging penguins to join in with the party celebrations? Neelyak and Metini
March 15, 2019 Greentastic Genre What is your favorite thing about the St. Patrick’s Parade? Blueice881 and Babycrier
March 22, 2019 Box Dimension What exactly is Box Dimension and where did it come from? Venusian and Xqpy
March 30, 2019 Dimensional Dilemma Which dimension do you enjoy the most and why? Peengi and dabluekid
April 6, 2019 Igloo Additions How are you going to use these new items to customise your igloo? Laurcha and Bunnywinter
April 12, 2019 Earth Day Preparations What are you doing to prepare for Earth Day? Gokemon and eeyore96
April 19, 2019 Helping Animals Which animal are you showing your support and dedication for and why? Dhiren Houck and Jozara
April 27, 2019 Puffles! Which puffle is your favorite and why? Hoppy26711 and Calistaaa12
May 4, 2019 Penguin Style What do you enjoy about the new releases of the Penguin Style catalogs? UghSky and The User
May 11, 2019 Pin Popularity What do you enjoy about finding pins hidden around the island? LizaRay and Owlson803
May 18, 2019 Musical Genres What music genre do you enjoy the most? GoldMax and RyanjcCPR
May 25, 2019 Jammin' Styles If you were in a band with your friends, what role would you play in it? Kayyleighh and penguin54974
June 1, 2019 Rocking the Show What was your favourite thing about the Music Jam? Bakhm and Mano Rookie
June 8, 2019 Western Yee-haw What do you enjoy about dressing up as a cowpenguin for this new event? neptian and shadowfight
June 15, 2019 Rockhopper Ahoy! What new goodies and secrets do you hope he will bring with him to the island? Exredo and FireSanti
June 22, 2019 Captains and Pirates Which team, Team Pirate or Team Captain would you say is better and why? peri wink and pinkuisabela
June 29, 2019 Barrel Search What do you most enjoy about collecting the hidden barrels hidden around the island? Sp2nnyB02 and Ditto432
July 6, 2019 Ye' Olde Preparations What are you doing to prepare for the Medieval Party? Nathroxx and Valery
July 13, 2019 Igloo Enhancements How are you using the new igloo locations feature to improve your igloo? eliefr and wetdog15
July 20, 2019 Mysterious Creature What do you think this sinister looking creature could be? Doreas and Acookie27
July 27, 2019 Sinister Earthquakes How are you playing your part to keep penguins safe around the island? JessieKnu and bluestk
August 5, 2019 Medieval Times Will you be battling against the furious Dragon Queen, or just enjoying the times? Luminocity and Ssmashleyy
August 10, 2019 Medieval Memories What are your favorite memories about the Medieval Party this year? Nadia2 and Ruby Cuty
August 17, 2019 Summer Time How are you celebrating your summer on the island? BerrySweets and cp famous
August 24, 2019 Stage Plays What is your favorite stage play and for what reason? Giggy13011 and SamSwitch64
August 31, 2019 Summer Fun What do you enjoy about the Summer Luau? Yohan67890 and Hsmace
September 7, 2019 Stadium Games Which team colour do you enjoy or playing as or supporting? Lily19530 and yolkimus
September 14, 2019 Pin Discovery How many pins have you obtained and which one is your favourite? alto bb and Luvseal
September 21, 2019 Fair Prizes Which new prize do you enjoy showing off in front of other penguins? frostycute and Icey Creams
September 28, 2019 Carnival Fun What did you enjoy doing most at The Fair this year? caralynrs and Logan3918
October 5, 2019 Halloween Fashions What spooky Halloween costume have you created? SkyeSparkle and Haydenpeng
October 12, 2019 Field-Ops What have you enjoyed about Field-Ops so far? Stevie88812 and Prince Blake
October 20, 2019 Spooky Celebrations What are you looking forward to this year’s Halloween Party? 15honey04 and Storm4100
October 26, 2019 Monster Panic How are you tricking and scaring your penguin buddies with the new sled transformation feature? RedKrabby 2 and Hot Autumn
November 2, 2019 Sled Invasion If you were stuck as a living sled forever, what would you do and why? capricornv and Maxi1450
November 9, 2019 Winter Trends How are you styling yourself up for this upcoming wintry season? Blueberry504 and CBSCARES
November 16, 2019 Stage Acting What do you enjoy about acting in stage plays? Pookyy and Kidguin596
November 23, 2019 Ice Sculptures Which ice sculpture is your favorite and why? Sweet Ari and Claw204
November 30, 2019 Snowball Fights What do you enjoy about having snowball fights with your friends? Trooper and tacocat54893
December 7, 2019 Holiday Spirit What gets you excited about the holiday season? chanks and LemonLife12
December 14, 2019 Holiday Calendar What are you hoping to see from the Holiday Calendar? WaveWaker and Swimmer8980
December 22, 2019 Festive Celebrations What is special about the Holiday Party to you? Stevie88812 and P2856048
December 28, 2019 2019 Rewind What did you enjoy about 2019 on the island? MrThig and Lily19530

Date Title Question Previous winners
January 5, 2020 New Styles What is your favourite item from the new edition of the Penguin Style? stardance590 and Sparklmagyq
January 12, 2020 Furniture Selections What do you enjoy about decorating your igloo? mald5 and xArabelllla
January 18, 2020 Flight Preparations What are you excited about seeing at the Festival of Lights? Static and verssachii
January 26, 2020 Festival of Lights What are your plans during the Festival of Lights this celebration? Conache and Perapin
February 2, 2020 Item of the Month What has been your favourite Item of the Month so far? Lani2 and Splosh Jnr
February 8, 2020 3rd Anniversary What has been your favourite memories on Club Penguin Rewritten? PepperFast and totiana123
February 15, 2020 Puffle Care What do you enjoy about caring for your puffles? Sisiax123 and moonshixne
February 22, 2020 Puffle Mania If you were able to stay as a puffle forever, what would you do and why? GalacticSir and PandaHeart26
February 29, 2020 Puffle Activities Which activities do you enjoy taking part in with your puffles? Seth4564 and Funfunny8
March 8, 2020 Minigames! What minigame is your favourite and for what reason? Liksyy and The Nitronic
March 15, 2020 Rockhopper's Arrival What do you enjoy most and look forward to when Rockhopper returns to the island? JJ The Cool and Lily19530
March 22, 2020 Fashion Party If you could choose a Fashion Party theme, what would it be and why? Blueicegram and norrabun
March 29, 2020 April Foolz! If you made a grand discovery of a new dimension, what kind of dimension would it be? Aquania1 and Bakhm
April 5, 2020 Penguin Mascots If you could meet any mascot, who would it be and for what reason? Splosh Jnr and Hot Autumn
April 11, 2020 Egg Searching What do you enjoy about scavenging for eggs around the island? ratsbian and Icey Creams
May 3, 2020 Penguin Play Awards With the results announced and the event almost over, what was your favourite part of the Penguin Play Awards? parrotsoul10 and xArabelllla
May 9, 2020 Hidden Rooms! Which hidden room do you like the most, and why? CheezyPie and TheNitronic


  • It is the successor of Question of the Day.
  • There was also a Reviewed by You on Club Penguin, which was where the idea came from.
  • Originally, only 1 penguin was going to be chosen per week, but due to so many submissions, it was increased to 2.
  • Reviewed by You has gone through a few schedule changes:
    • From May 2018 to April 2019, they were primarily posted on Fridays.
    • From May 2019 to February 2020, they were primarily posted on Saturdays.
    • Since March 2020, they have primarily been posted on Sundays.


Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.